"Will this look good on my college application?"
One of the most common questions I hear from students and families is some version of: "What should I (my child) do to stand out?"
It is about an extracurricular activity: Should I start a club? Conduct research? Pursue an internship? Attend a summer program?
Or about academics: Which course will look better? Which major should I choose? Is one area of interest more compelling than another? Essentially their question all comes down to, "What do colleges want to see?"
I understand that strategy can feel reassuring especially in times of uncertainty. I also understand that students want to make thoughtful choices about how they spend their limited time. But I also notice that underneath these questions may be an underlying belief that there is some ideal version of a college applicant. It is tempting to imagine that selective colleges are searching for a particular type (with highest GPA, most leadership, unusual extracurricular activities...), because a clear-cut answer can mean a clear-cut strategy. However, just as we are each a unique and original individual, we must remember that students naturally arrive at the admissions process from profoundly different circumstances, and the admissions committee knows that. There is no short cut or a magic formula; even if you were to be strategic, and it shouldn't be with 'a cookie-cutter' approach. That is why I encourage students to turn the outward question, ‘Which activity looks most impressive?’, into an inward one: ‘Why does this matter to me?'
Authenticity vs Strategy
There is nothing wrong with being admission-conscious. But if that becomes the driving principle, a student would spend four years building a résumé instead of building a life. The concern is, by doing so, their application may become less distinguished or appealing, not more.
From my former admissions roles, I know that the strongest applications are not manufactured. They are often developed over time, through original choices that make sense for that particular student. That is my approach in college advisory: authenticity and strategy can coexist. One doesn't need to replace the other. Good strategy is most powerful when it supports what's already genuinely there. I believe that what contributes to my success in the college advisory role is not my former admissions background alone, but my ability to genuinely see, discover, and capture the true best in each and every student. And that is strategy, too.
The Committee Room's Approach
As you begin this process, I hope you remember that high school students are still in the process of becoming themselves. It is my philosophy as an educator that a ninth grader should be allowed to try something and discover what works and doesn't for them. A tenth grader should be able to change direction, and an eleventh grader should be able to become fascinated by something no one predicted two years earlier. Lastly, a twelfth grader, too, should be allowed to continue being and becoming themselves.
Not every choice needs to advance a carefully constructed admissions narrative. Some experiences are valuable simply because they teach one something about who they are/aren't. College planning should provide direction without eliminating discovery. I would rather see a student develop a few real interests with depth than spend years anxiously patching evidence of impressiveness that is in fact meaningless to them. And I would help a student make thoughtful choices, not teach them to perform a version of themselves.
Eventually, every application becomes a document: years of hard work appear on a single-page transcript with simple numeric values, activities that the student poured heart and hours into become condensed descriptions, and the student needs to show who they are in 650 words. I understand that there is some artificiality to that process. My goal is, then, not to make the student more artificial but to preserve as much of who they are as possible.
When we watch movies, we don't get most excited to watch a perfectly fine character living through an astonishingly orderly life (cue "Everything is Awesome!" in The Lego Movie). We are likely more charmed by (and rooting for) the characters who go through life's ups and downs, sometimes fall, but stand back up, evolve, and grow into the better versions of themselves. Why? I would love to hear your own answers to this question.
The strongest application is not a manufactured version of who a student believes colleges want them to be. It is the clearest, most thoughtful expression of who they are—as students, community members, and human beings—and who they are still becoming.