What Matters in a College Application Essay?
Students have spent their K-12 years learning how to write. They are taught to construct arguments, organize paragraphs, use some appropriate SAT vocabulary, and avoid grammatical errors. But a college application essay is not an English paper; it asks for something different in nature. It is not mainly about how well you can write, or about how creative you can be, but more about "Can you show (not tell) who you are?" in limited amount of words.
It requires voice. And as you may know, one's original voice can get lost quickly when they are too mindful about impressing the reader. More so than a writer's block, that loss of originality is what I am most cautious about when working with students on their essays.
High school juniors and seniors are genuinely fun to work with, because they can be insightful and uncertain at the same time. And I believe that is the real beauty of a seventeen-year-old's voice in their writing; making the college essay more sophisticated is not always better. When a parent or another adult tries to restructure a whole paragraph, or over-edits, without realizing, the student's voice often fades away from their own writing.
That is why essay coaching requires expertise not just in writing well, but more so in finding the right balance and restraint. When I review a student’s work, I ask myself: What is this student trying to say, and how can I help them say it more fully in their own voice?
The 'Right' Topic
Students frequently ask me whether a topic is unique enough for a college essay, or if their intro sentence is 'hook' enough.
In most cases, however, I am less interested in the topic itself. I am more focused on what the student does with it. For instance, a dramatic experience does not automatically produce a memorable essay. In fact, some extraordinary experiences produce surprisingly generic essays because often, the event itself does all the work and takes the spotlight. On the other hand, a seemingly ordinary experience can become deeply compelling through the words of a reflective student.
On Revision and Essay Coaching
Revision is a necessity. No matter how talented a writer is, no one's first draft can be their final draft.
Good coaching can help a student recognize where reflection could go further or where a paragraph has too many things at once. Great coaching comes from understanding the student, taking a deeper dive and discovering their thought process sometimes even before they bring them out on the surface. At the same time, there is also a line between helping a student discover what they mean and implanting the meaning for them. My role is not to hand a student better sentences; it is to ask the right questions that guide them while not pushing my own thoughts. Editing should never replace the student's voice. It is the very thing that must be preserved, and that is an uncompromising ethic of a good essay coach.