'The Committee Room'
Students and families work for months, or years, to build their best possible college application. And yet, as the student presses the submit button on the Common App with mixed emotions, it almost feels as if that application just disappears into a black hole, into a room where they cannot peek into.
That imagery may be a bit dramatic in our students' minds, yet that is also how I felt when I was mailing out my paper applications with sweaty palms at a post office in early 2000's. I empathize when students feel as if they have no control over how their applications will be evaluated, and how daunting and stressful that feels like. And now in 2026, while social media is often useful, it does not help that online media is flooded with unfiltered myths and rumors about what happens in the admissions office.
About a decade after my own high school senior year, I had the opportunity to actually experience the process from inside that room. The highlight of being an admissions officer was meeting students on the road (I'm good at remembering names and faces) and presenting at information sessions, but other integral parts of the role were reading applications, preparing for committee meetings, and participating in the voting process. Years later, I've also had the privilege of experiencing the process from the other side, this time advocating for the students.
Having experienced both sides of the admissions process has shaped the way I practice college advising. I often think back to the mind of the admissions committee; there is value in approaching this process with clarity, intention, and a real understanding of how the person on the other side may read what you have chosen to put forward. That is one of the reasons why I founded The Committee Room. Before your application enters the room, I want to help my students understand how it will be read.
What Actually Happens Inside That Room?
The phrase “admissions committee” may sound like it's shrouded in a veil from the outside. But in reality, I hope my students remember that it is simply a room full of people doing something human and humane: reading, interpreting, thinking, asking questions, and exchanging perspectives before coming to important decisions.
Different institutions conduct this process differently, and admissions processes constantly evolve. There is no universal script for what happens in a committee room; applications are not simply fed into a formula that produces fixed results, which also means that the strongest applications are not manufactured.
Context matters. A particular course selection may become meaningful given the student’s academic interests, and an activity that appears modest on paper may reveal something important in the context of a student’s opportunities. On the other hand, an application may contain many interesting pieces and still leave a reader wondering who the student actually is. That is why when I work with a student, I constantly think: What will the committee know about this student when all of these pieces are presented together?
Sitting in the committee, the applications I found most compelling were not necessarily those that were most polished. They were the ones in which I could vividly envision a seventeen-year-old giving their very best in what they genuinely care about, and offering a glimpse (or abundance) of hope that they would continue to bring that light to our campus community.